Share: 
A gift I wish I could return
Posted on 4/18/2012 at 6:41 AM EST   (402 days ago)
 
Single Image

Reviewer: Chops   (loved, 293 of 543 reviews)
Beer Name: The Gift
Brewery: Starr Hill Brewing Co.
Beer Style: Maibock/Helles Bock
Category: Bock
Stats: 6.5% ABV, 25 IBUs
                   
Fair
1 Member Rating | Fair Overall | 5/10 Appearance | 5/10 Aroma | 4/10 Mouthfeel | 4/10 Flavor
On a recent trip to Virginia, I had the pleasure of sampling many regional offerings. Virginia may not be a hot destination on the craft brew map, but they are certainly home to an array of interesting breweries. One of these is Star Hill based in Crozet, Virginia. My only experience with Star Hill to date has been with their Festie Oktoberfest brew, which left me very underwhelmed. So as an avid bock fan with one disappointment under my belt, the odds were stacked against Star Hill going into The Gift, their WinterBock Lager.

In the glass, The Gift has a deep reddish amber coloration. It comes with a frothy white head that dissipates quickly. The aroma consists of a pungent sweet candied malt that actually comes across as cherry cough syrup. At this point I had to revisit the label because there wasn't much bock about this beer. To my eyes and nose, The Gift comes across as more of an overly sweet amber with no hop profile. Not exactly the best of introductions.

Surprisingly, the taste closely matches the aroma. The primary flavor is that of an overly sweet malt with a bubblegum vibe that reminded me of cough syrup. Oddly enough, it's not that bad. I wouldn't considered it a pleasant taste by any means, but it was actually okay. Unfortunately the hop profile is very imbalanced and appears only as occasional bitter pops. The finish ended up being decently clean, but forgettable.

Overall, Star Hill's The Gift WinterBock Lager is a very strange beer. I can say with great clarity that it's not a good bock, not even close. To me, it's nothing more than an overly sweet amber. But in that category, it's okay. I can't really recommend it to any camp because it's just too much of an oddball. I would imagine that The Gift would be appealing to some fans of malty sweet beers, but even there it's a crap shoot. Drink it in a pinch, but that's about it. This is a gift I wish I could return.
Rate This Review:   Love (0)   Like (5)   Respect (1)   Dislike (0)   Hate (0)
 
Helpful Link  |  Event Page  |  Must Try  |  More Reviews  |  Print View
Member Comments (2)
 

Posted on 4/18/2012 at 1:29 PM EST by Brew's Your Daddy (loved)
I remember going through a stretch of beers like this one a while back. If it were to be blindly placed in front of you with no bottle or label or background material, it would be at least a drinkable brew. But what you introduce the information about it, things can really get confusing.

Posted on 4/18/2012 at 4:53 PM EST by Chops (loved)
Heh, confusing is an understatement. I have noticed that breweries tend to be repeat offenders in this arena. It really perplexes me because there are many breweries out there with huge product lines that are able to appropriately classify each and every brew. I mean really, how hard can it be? It's almost like some brewers have a skewed style perspective.

Post a Comment




Wish to advertise
on BrewChief.com?
Contact us about
rates and details.
Disclaimers
© Copyright
2011-2013
BrewChief.com
All Rights Reserved
Helpful Pics Disclaimer

Helpful Pics are the sole property of the reviewer and are meant for educational purposes only. Please do not reuse without the reviewer's consent.


BBCode Support

At this point BrewChief only supports BBCode for italics and URLs, which are usable in commentaries, responses and profile descriptions. We may offer more formatting options in the future, but for now we would like the website to remain visually standardized.

Please note that BBCode is case sensitive and tags should always be in lower case format.

How to use BBCode for URLs:

Format:  [url]http://www.brewchief.com[/url]

Result:  http://www.brewchief.com

How to use BBCode for italics:

Format:  [i]This sentence is in italics.[/i]

Result:  This sentence is in italics.