Share: 
I wanted to believe
Posted on 6/30/2012 at 5:26 PM EST   (324 days ago)
 
Single Image

Reviewer: Brew's Your Daddy   (loved, 216 of 262 reviews)
Beer Name: Guinness Draught
Brewery: Guinness Ltd.
Beer Style: Dry Stout
Category: Stout
Stats: 4.2% ABV
                   
Fair
2 Member Ratings | Delicious Overall | 3/10 Appearance | 5/10 Aroma | 6/10 Mouthfeel | 6/10 Flavor
I'm no psychic, but I would be willing to bet that if you are over the age of 30, I can guess where your first taste of a stout came from. It wasn't from some crazy and creative craft brewery. Nope. Those are still, in relative terms, new in this style scene. It probably wasn't from some American brewery in general, considering that their interest in the stout world didn't blossom until a few years ago. Chances are the first time you got a sip of my favorite style, one beer in particular sat squarely in front of you on the bar, and that beer was none other than a Guinness. I will take a pause for you to reflect on that magical moment as I do the same. Pretty awesome, right? Ok, let's continue. Now that technology in the beer world has advanced by leaps and bounds, the people at Guinness Ltd. now offer a version of their Guinness Draught designed to be enjoyed straight from the bottle. I know what you are thinking. ''You mean we can take Guinness with us anywhere and skip the pint glass completely?'' The simple answer is ''Yes'', while the more detailed answer is ''Not exactly''.

Now seeing as how it is designed to be drank straight from the bottle, you lose a lot of the Guinness glory right off the bat. There is no signature tan head waterfall, nor is there a stark black appearance that refuses to let even the slightest amount of light pass through. You have a bottle to look at. Granted it has a few more curves than the standard bottle we normally see, but it still isn't the same as the visual we have all grown accustomed to seeing as a nice pint is presented to us at a bar. And while we are at it, go ahead and try to get some aromas out of that tiny little bottle opening. While it will provide plenty of entertainment for anyone in visual range of you, other than a bit of a charred malt aroma, that is about the only thing that will come out of it.

After a bit of research on the Guinness Ltd. website, I came across this passage:

The signature Guinness Draught experience is activated every time you tilt the bottle to drink. The nitrogen contained in the new gas mix is released by the tilting action – that’s why it’s best consumed straight from the bottle.

Well I for one really hoped that this was true and some real Guinness flavor came through considering what I had to give up for the convenience of getting to carry it around in a bottle. I mean, if I don't get to look at it, it better at least taste like it right? Unfortunately, there is a let down here as well. There is a bit of a dark, roasted malt flavor, along with a hint of cocoa powder and some weak coffee, but that's about it. And even they are very...muted...at best. Tilt after tilt, the taste never changed, and besides a lingering, slightly tinny metallic aftertaste, not much came from the bottle for me. Even the signature creamy mouthfeel comes across as a bit watery and thin.

I really hate to rip the beer that introduced me to the style I have come to love, but in this case I think we both get a break. I know, I know. Just bear with me. The Guinness Draught that is presented to you in a bar, fresh from the tap, still upholds the standard that it set so many years ago. But the Guinness Draught that finds itself imprisoned in a bottle is a whole different story. In a nutshell, it tastes like a regular Guinness that was allowed to go flat, and then about an ounce of water was added to it. Not horrific, but not top notch either. Think of it as an ''in a pinch'' option. Odds are you can find it at most any grocery store or gas station, which means it can keep you far away from the mass produced corporate garbage. Other than that though, if you find yourself at a bar or store with a decent brew selection, you can definitely do better.
Rate This Review:   Love (1)   Like (5)   Respect (0)   Dislike (0)   Hate (0)
 
Helpful Link  |  Must Try  |  More Reviews  |  Print View
Member Comments (3)
 

Posted on 7/1/2012 at 12:47 PM EST by Chops (loved)
To be perfectly honest, I lost some respect for Guinness the second this bottle hit the market. Techno gimmicks aside, I can at least understand why they did it, i.e. they want a piece of the "grab and go" market share. But, Guinness just isn't a grab and go beer. Any beer fan who regularly sits at a bar and enjoys a pint of Guinness already knows that expectations matter. If you can't see or smell the beer before you drink it, you're only setting yourself up for disappointment. No matter how advanced their technology gets, no bottle will ever replace the pint glass.

Posted on 7/2/2012 at 12:12 AM EST by Brew's Your Daddy (loved)
I 100% agree about the expectations that Guinness has set in all our minds. Even their commercials from the past were largely based on the visual appearance of their product. It would be like Ferrari constantly advertising "We go fast! We are fast! Holy crap are our cars amazingly fast!" and then they put out a 4 cylinder version of their Spider. Yeah, I mean I would drive it, but I would totally feel like I got the raw end of the deal somehow.

Posted on 10/21/2012 at 4:52 PM EST by JuicesFlowing (liked)
I went to Dublin in 2008, and visited the Guinness Storehouse. 99.9% of the beers I drank that week were Guinness in pubs, and they were absolutely fantastic. Guinness gets a bad rap in the States because of the pub cans, and the bottles must be awful in comparison. I will always respect Guinness for introducing me to the stout world. Having said that, I think Murphy's make a superior pub can in the states. Beamish is also good. I love Guinness, but rarely drink it, because it seems so watered down and commercial now. But not on tap in Ireland.

Post a Comment




Wish to advertise
on BrewChief.com?
Contact us about
rates and details.
Disclaimers
© Copyright
2011-2013
BrewChief.com
All Rights Reserved
Helpful Pics Disclaimer

Helpful Pics are the sole property of the reviewer and are meant for educational purposes only. Please do not reuse without the reviewer's consent.


BBCode Support

At this point BrewChief only supports BBCode for italics and URLs, which are usable in commentaries, responses and profile descriptions. We may offer more formatting options in the future, but for now we would like the website to remain visually standardized.

Please note that BBCode is case sensitive and tags should always be in lower case format.

How to use BBCode for URLs:

Format:  [url]http://www.brewchief.com[/url]

Result:  http://www.brewchief.com

How to use BBCode for italics:

Format:  [i]This sentence is in italics.[/i]

Result:  This sentence is in italics.